Lilith: Origin of Succubi
Chapter 129
- Chapter 358
- Chapter 357
- Chapter 356
- Chapter 355
- Chapter 354
- Chapter 353
- Chapter 352
- Chapter 351
- Chapter 350
- Chapter 349
- Chapter 348
- Chapter 347
- Chapter 346
- Chapter 345
- Chapter 344
- Chapter 343
- Chapter 342
- Chapter 341
- Chapter 340
- Chapter 339
- Chapter 338
- Chapter 337
- Chapter 336
- Chapter 335
- Chapter 334
- Chapter 333
- Chapter 332
- Chapter 331
- Chapter 330
- Chapter 329
- Book 6 – Chapter 328
- Chapter 327
- Chapter 326
- Chapter 325
- Chapter 324
- Chapter 323
- Chapter 322
- Chapter 321
- Chapter 320
- Chapter 319
- Chapter 318
- Chapter 317
- Chapter 316
- Chapter 315
- Chapter 314
- Chapter 313
- Chapter 312
- Chapter 311
- Chapter 310
- Chapter 309
- Chapter 308
- Chapter 307
- Chapter 306
- Chapter 305
- Chapter 304
- Chapter 303
- Chapter 302
- Chapter 301
- Chapter 300
- Chapter 299
- Chapter 298
- Chapter 297
- Chapter 296
- Chapter 295
- Chapter 294
- Chapter 293
- Chapter 292
- Chapter 291
- Chapter 290
- Chapterr 289
- Chapter 288
- Chapter 287
- Chapter 286
- Chapter 285
- Chapter 284
- Chapter 283
- Chapter 282
- Chapter 281
- Chapter 280
- Chapter 279
- Chapter 278
- Chapter 277
- Chapter 276
- Chapter 275
- Chapter 274
- Chapter 273
- Chapter 272
- Chapter 271
- Chapter 270
- Chapter 269
- Chapter 268
- Chapter 267
- Chapter 266
- Chapter 265
- Chapter 264
- Chapter 263
- Chapter 262
- Chapter 261
- Chapter 260
- Chapter 259
- Chapter 258
- Chapter 257
- Chapter 256
- Chapter 255
- Chapter 254
- Chapter 253
- Chapter 252
- Chapter 251
- Chapter 250
- Book 5 – Chapter 249
- Chapter 248
- Chapter 247
- Chapter 246
- Chapter 245
- Chapter 244
- Chapter 243
- Chapter 242
- Chapter 241
- Chapter 240
- Chapter 239
- Chapter 238
- Chapter 237
- Chapter 236
- Chapter 235
- Chapter 234
- Chapter 233
- Chapter 232
- Chapter 231
- Chapter 230
- Chapter 229
- Chapter 228
- Chapter 227
- Chapter 226
- Chapter 225
- Chapter 224
- Chapter 223
- Chapter 222
- Chapter 221
- Chapter 220
- Chapter 219
- Chapter 218
- Chapter 217
- Chapter 216
- Chapter 215
- Chapter 214
- Chapter 213
- Chapter 212
- Chapter 211
- Chapter 210
- Chapter 209
- Chapter 208
- Chapter 207
- Chapter 206
- Chapter 205
- Chapter 204
- Chapter 203
- Chapter 202
- Chapter 201
- Chapter 200
- Chapter 199
- Chapter 198
- Chapter 197
- Chapter 196
- Chapter 195
- Chapter 194
- Chapter 193
- Chapter 192
- Chapter 191
- Chapter 190
- Chapter 189
- Chapter 188
- Chapter 187
- Chapter 186
- Chapter 185
- Chapter 184
- Chapter 183
- Chapter 182
- Chapter 181
- Chapter 180
- Chapter 179
- Chapter 178
- Chapter 177
- Chapter 176
- Chapter 175
- Chapter 174
- Chapter 173
- Chapter 172
- Chapter 171
- Chapter 170
- Chapter 169
- Chapter 168
- Chapter 167
- Chapter 166
- Chapter 165
- Chapter 164
- Chapter 163
- Chapter 162
- Chapter 161
- Chapter 160
- Chapter 159
- Chapter 158
- Chapter 157
- Chapter 156
- Chapter 155
- Chapter 154
- Chapter 153
- Chapter 152
- Chapter 151
- Chapter 150
- Chapter 149
- Chapter 148
- Chapter 147
- Chapter 146
- Chapter 145
- Chapter 144
- Chapter 143
- Chapter 142
- Chapter 141
- Chapter 140
- Chapter 139
- Chapter 138
- Chapter 137
- Chapter 136
- Chapter 135
- Chapter 134
- Chapter 133
- Chapter 132
- Chapter 131
- Chapter 130
- Chapter 129
- Chapter 128
- Chapter 127
- Chapter 126
- Chapter 125
- Chapter 124
- Chapter 123
- Chapter 122
- Chapter 121
- Chapter 120
- Chapter 119
- Chapter 118
- Chapter 117
- Chapter 116
- Chapter 115
- Chapter 114
- Chapter 113
- Chapter 112
- Chapter 111
- Chapter 110
- Chapter 109
- Chapter 108
- Chapter 107
- Chapter 106
- Chapter 105
- Chapter 104
- Chapter 103
- Chapter 102
- Chapter 101
- Chapter 100
- Chapter 99
- Chapter 98
- Chapter 97
- Chapter 96
- Chapter 95
- Chapter 94
- Chapter 93
- Chapter 92
- Chapter 91
- Chapter 90
- Chapter 89
- Chapter 88
- Chapter 87
- Chapter 86
- Chapter 85
- Chapter 84
- Chapter 83
- Chapter 82
- Chapter 81
- Chapter 80
- Chapter 79
- Chapter 78
- Chapter 77
- Chapter 76
- Chapter 75
- Chapter 74
- Chapter 73
- Chapter 72
- Chapter 71
- Chapter 70
- Chapter 69
- Chapter 68
- Chapter 67
- Chapter 66
- Chapter 65
- Chapter 64
- Chapter 63
- Chapter 62
- Chapter 61
- Chapter 60
- Chapter 59
- Chapter 58
- Chapter 57
- Chapter 56
- Chapter 55
- Chapter 54
- Chapter 53
- Chapter 52
- Chapter 51
- Chapter 50
- Chapter 49
- Chapter 48
- Chapter 47
- Chapter 46
- Chapter 45
- Chapter 44
- Chapter 43
- Chapter 42
- Chapter 41
- Chapter 40
- Chapter 39
- Chapter 38
- Chapter 37
- Chapter 36
- Chapter 35
- Chapter 34
- Chapter 33
- Chapter 32
- Chapter 31
- Chapter 30
- Chapter 29
- Chapter 28
- Chapter 27
- Chapter 26
- Chapter 25
- Chapter 24
- Chapter 23
- Chapter 22
- Chapter 21
- Chapter 20
- Chapter 19
- Chapter 18
- Chapter 17
- Chapter 16
- Chapter 15
- Chapter 14
- Chapter 13
- Chapter 12
- Chapter 11
- Chapter 10
- Chapter 9
- Chapter 8
- Chapter 7
- Chapter 6
- Chapter 5
- Chapter 4
- Chapter 3
- Chapter 2
- Chapter 1
After the battle all of the guards took a break to recover from the fight and secure the area. I wasn't the only one that leveled and it was pretty obvious based on all the people who were standing around staring into space. There weren't any casualties and it didn't take long for Bella to patch up the few people who had gotten some minor injuries, so everyone was in good spirits.
"How about you guys? Did all of you level too?" I turned to my friends to see that glassy look in their eyes as well.
All of them nodded, there were smiles all around.
Torien stopped staring into space and looked over at me. "That thing must have out-leveled us by quite a bit, I got more than one main level."
"Any new interesting skills or spells?" I asked.
"Mmm, my class has been leaning towards a scout role for a while now. It seems clearing out rooms while watching for demons has influenced the new skill I got. It's an ability that helps me better at spotting clues, tracks, or anything out of place. Pretty useful considering some of the reasons we came here in the first place."
I nodded. "That's true. How about you Bella?"
She blinked a few times before turning to me. "Ah, I actually got two new abilities related to healing. Until now a lot of the abilities have been focused on nature control, things like [Entangling Roots], but I've been healing so much lately I got two new abilities related to that. I was hoping I would get a more powerful healing spell but instead, I got something that lets me heal multiple people at once and something that lets me heal at range. Probably more useful for the kind of stuff we usually do so I'm quite happy about it."
Morrigan shoulder-bumped me. "How about you?"
I laughed. "I actually haven't looked yet."
"Then stop bothering us and look!" She grinned and pushed me away.
"Alright, alright." I smiled and brought the notifications back up.
[Your level has increased from level 41 to level 42]
[Novice Magic Swordsman has increased from level 9 to level 10]
[Luck Magic has increased from level 1 to level 6]
[Light Magic has increased from level 9 to level 10]
[Light Manipulation has increased from level 9 to level 12]
One main level and one class level. Not bad considering my participation was mainly relegated to support. I wasn't sure how strong the guards we fought with were but I was sure they were above our level. I can usually tell based on that weird feeling Silva told me about but there are so many of them and they're close enough in level to me that it's harder to tell. Mimi probably knows but I'm not actually interested enough to ask.
I got five levels in luck magic, another in light magic, and three more in light manipulation. I did a lot of on-the-fly modifications of my light magic, so that makes sense. I think what I did with fireflies and the light beam was probably my most significant contribution to the fight so it's not a surprise that I leveled in both of those related skills. I'm pretty sure most of the experience I gained in luck magic was because it was the first time I used it in combat not because it was all that useful in the scheme of things. Five levels aren't anything to complain about though.
[Learned Enhancement Magic Spell Light Imbue]
[Learned Light Magic Spell Light Ward]
[Learned Luck Magic Spell A Touch of Good Luck]
[Light Imbue - Enchantment Magic Spell]
Imbue a weapon or object with Light magic making it glow and apply light damage when it hits enemies. Light Imbue can only damage dark and shadow aligned enemies. The strength of the enchantment is increased by Magic Force and the duration of the enchantment is increased by Magic Control. Larger weapons and objects take a proportionally larger amount of magic to enchant. Light Imbue can be applied to others' weapons but the wielder of the weapon determines who is considered an enemy for the purposes of this spell. The effects of objects imbued with light vary.
Very similar to [Flame Imbue] but arguably a worthless variant. There could be subtle benefits to [Light Imbue] such as heatless glowing items and it should be more helpful against other shadow and dark monsters, but past that, the applications seem minimal.
[Light Ward - Light Magic Spell]
Create a pane of light that can block or deflect physical and magic damage. Strength of the barrier is affected by Magic Force and Magic Control. Brightness and size are affected by Magic Force. Color, shape, and range are affected by Magic Control. Light Ward is weak against shadow and dark-aligned attacks.
Now this seems like a good spell. This is the first spell I've gotten that's had any kind of defensive properties, everything until now has been either offensive or utility-focused. Feeling out the spell, I could also tell that I would have a decent amount of control over how the spell looked as well.
I cast the spell in front of me and a simple slightly glowing pane of blue glass-like light appeared. There was something amusing about creating the quintessential status window as the first thing I did with the ability. I obviously didn't actually put my status on it, I wasn't stupid, but I was able to write some text and display it on the pane of light by combining it with my [Light Signal] spell.
"Oh Lilith! What's that?" Morrigan came right over, looking intrigued by my experimentation.
"It's my new ability, [Light Ward] it lets me create a defensive barrier. I'm messing around and combining it with [Light Signal]."
Torien looked at me incredulously. "You get a barrier spell and the first thing you do with it isn't, you know, block an attack. It's write a message on it?"
"Tori! Knock it off, I like it when Lilith experiments with her magic. She's been able to do some neat stuff with it. And despite what a lot of people have said about the usefulness of light magic, that last fight went as smoothly as it did because of her ability to adapt her light magic spells." Morrigan looked cute defending me like that.
"I'm not trying to discourage her from experimenting. It's just so like her to mess around like that." Torien shrugged.
Bella sighed. "As long as she doesn't do it while we're relaxing I'm fine. When she first got her light magic she started giving me a headache with how much she was making it shine and fly around the room. When she started making rainbows flash all over the book I was reading I had to ask her to stop."
I laughed. "Yeah! I remember that. I was so excited to use magic for the first time that I wanted to figure out everything I could about it. I was messing around so much that I ended up unlocking [Light Manipulation] through that. I'm really glad I did though, it's allowed me to do a lot more with my light magic than I could have without it."
Morrigan nodded in agreement. "Many mages neglect magic control and the associated manipulation skills. Some mages make the mistake that more power is always better and then they get tripped up when a little bit of magic control would solve their problems more efficiently. It's one of my biggest shortcomings, because I have to rely on wild magic it's harder for me to practice with individual manipulation skills. I'm somewhat proficient in everything but I'll never have the skill of someone who can specialize in one particular element."
I scratched my horn while thinking. "Yeah, the jack of all trades problem."
"What's that?" Morrigan asked.
"Oh, I suppose I should explain. Where I come from there's a saying that gets interpreted in a few different ways. If I remember correctly it goes something like, 'Jack of all trades, master of none. Oftentimes better than a master of one.' However the second line is very often omitted. There are a few different ways that people end up thinking about a 'jack of all trades,' but it usually comes down to whether you favor versatility or specialization. Being good at a large number of different things allows you to combine your skills in ways that might be greater than the sum of their parts. At the same time, being the best at one thing does have its advantages as well."
Mimi suddenly spoke up, "What do you think? Which do you favor?"
I smiled. "I've always been in the camp of versatility. Don't get me wrong, there are times when calling a specialist is the right call but there is also something called the 80-20 rule where I come from. This is another thing that isn't a hard and fast universal truth or anything, but it goes, '80 percent of results come from the first 20 percent of effort.' or something like that, there are lots of variants to that one. The idea is, if you look at most skills, 20 percent of mastery will usually get you 80 percent of what you need from it. Obviously that isn't always true but you can usually get a lot done with that first 20 percent. If you get 20 percent good at a lot of different things, your skills can combine in ways that you don't expect and bring you a lot more value than you would think. It allows you to be a generalist. That's the way I look at things anyway."
Morrigan leaned on me and set her head on my shoulder. "Lilith... I love you. I've always felt... lesser than other mages or... real mages as I sometimes think of them. Your way of thinking makes me feel... I don't know, special. Like I have a strength that others don't."
I patted her on the leg. "Are you kidding? You kept hurling fireballs that entire fight, I had to reserve my mana just in case I needed it later. You have tons of advantages. Everything has trade offs but quantity is a quality all its own."
Silva smirked at me. "You sure do have a lot of sayings where you come from."
I laughed in response. "That's true."
Sometimes the magic that translates everything between us translates the meaning of my sayings directly, other times they have to ask me what a word is or what the saying means. The logic behind what is translated cleanly and what isn't is really muddy. It catches me off guard sometimes.
Anyway, I have one last spell to look at.
[A Touch of Good Luck - Luck Magic Spell]
Touch a friend and wish them luck. The magnitude of this effect is affected by [Luck].
I stared at the incredibly short and unhelpful message. That's it?
I looked over and patted Morrigan on the shoulder and activated the spell. "Good luck." I felt the spell trigger and take a small amount of mana. It did something but it's unclear what.
Morrigan turned to me in confusion. "Er, thanks?"
I shrugged and smiled. "New spell."
Morrigan's ears perked up. "What's it do?" 𝑓𝑟𝑒𝘦𝓌𝑒𝑏𝑛𝑜𝘷𝑒𝘭.𝒸𝘰𝑚
"Gives you good luck. That's basically all it says."
Her brows furrowed. "Odd, That's all it says?"
"Touch a friend and wish them luck. The magnitude of this effect is affected by Luck."
"Weird. Maybe not surprising considering the uncharted territory of luck magic."
"Yeah, I thought I would test it out. It certainly did something, I felt it take mana, no idea how strong the effect is or how long it lasts," I said.
I noticed Jasper walking up to us. "Lilith, I wanted to come thank you and your friends. When we were first told about your participation today I wasn't sure how useful you would be but that spell you used was very helpful." He turned to my friends. "And all of you coordinated well with my men. You have my thanks." He nodded and focused on me again. "We're planning on getting back to clearing the rest of the floor soon. Make sure you and your group finish looking through your status if you haven't already and prepare to move on."
I nodded. "Sure, I appreciate the kind words."
Jasper smiled and walked away.
"Prick."
I turned to look at Silva. "What's wrong?"
She shook her head. "There's something about that guy. I don't trust him. I can't tell you what it is but... I don't know. He's condescending."
Torien furrowed her brows. "He didn't come off that way to me..."
Silva shrugged. "Maybe it's nothing. Just be careful."
I nodded. "Noted."
It's not like I knew the guy well. I didn't have any reason to believe this was some kind of trap though and the guy has been pretty nice so far. It doesn't hurt to stay on guard if one of my friends has a bad feeling but I haven't noticed anything myself yet.
I glanced over at him, he has 1863 positive karma but it can always be tricky to rely on that. It's not the highest number but it's also far from negative. Most of the nearby guards have worse karma than he does but he's also the captain and has been around longer. I can't really make a solid judgement based on his karma alone.
I scratched the base of my horn. "Go ahead and keep an eye on him but don't do anything unless he's overtly attacking one of us. Come find me if it's something important, otherwise Torien is still in charge. I trust her judgement. Don't take any unnecessary risks, the most important thing is that we all come out safe."
Silva nodded in response but didn't speak. It was hard for me to tell if Silva was just being paranoid but I couldn't take any chances in a situation with demons around every corner, literally.
Maybe ten or fifteen minutes later the ballroom was completely cleared and our groups were spread along one wall where many of the service doors reentered the castle proper. Instead of barricading all of the doors, it was easier to just go through all of the small doors at once and methodically search for the demons this time around. The two groups from my party members were spaced out at the thirds, likely to improve our coverage in the connected rooms and root out any hiding demons.
"Alright everyone! Advance!"
I took a deep breath and gripped my sword as the doors swung open and we moved to the next phase.
- Chapter 358
- Chapter 357
- Chapter 356
- Chapter 355
- Chapter 354
- Chapter 353
- Chapter 352
- Chapter 351
- Chapter 350
- Chapter 349
- Chapter 348
- Chapter 347
- Chapter 346
- Chapter 345
- Chapter 344
- Chapter 343
- Chapter 342
- Chapter 341
- Chapter 340
- Chapter 339
- Chapter 338
- Chapter 337
- Chapter 336
- Chapter 335
- Chapter 334
- Chapter 333
- Chapter 332
- Chapter 331
- Chapter 330
- Chapter 329
- Book 6 – Chapter 328
- Chapter 327
- Chapter 326
- Chapter 325
- Chapter 324
- Chapter 323
- Chapter 322
- Chapter 321
- Chapter 320
- Chapter 319
- Chapter 318
- Chapter 317
- Chapter 316
- Chapter 315
- Chapter 314
- Chapter 313
- Chapter 312
- Chapter 311
- Chapter 310
- Chapter 309
- Chapter 308
- Chapter 307
- Chapter 306
- Chapter 305
- Chapter 304
- Chapter 303
- Chapter 302
- Chapter 301
- Chapter 300
- Chapter 299
- Chapter 298
- Chapter 297
- Chapter 296
- Chapter 295
- Chapter 294
- Chapter 293
- Chapter 292
- Chapter 291
- Chapter 290
- Chapterr 289
- Chapter 288
- Chapter 287
- Chapter 286
- Chapter 285
- Chapter 284
- Chapter 283
- Chapter 282
- Chapter 281
- Chapter 280
- Chapter 279
- Chapter 278
- Chapter 277
- Chapter 276
- Chapter 275
- Chapter 274
- Chapter 273
- Chapter 272
- Chapter 271
- Chapter 270
- Chapter 269
- Chapter 268
- Chapter 267
- Chapter 266
- Chapter 265
- Chapter 264
- Chapter 263
- Chapter 262
- Chapter 261
- Chapter 260
- Chapter 259
- Chapter 258
- Chapter 257
- Chapter 256
- Chapter 255
- Chapter 254
- Chapter 253
- Chapter 252
- Chapter 251
- Chapter 250
- Book 5 – Chapter 249
- Chapter 248
- Chapter 247
- Chapter 246
- Chapter 245
- Chapter 244
- Chapter 243
- Chapter 242
- Chapter 241
- Chapter 240
- Chapter 239
- Chapter 238
- Chapter 237
- Chapter 236
- Chapter 235
- Chapter 234
- Chapter 233
- Chapter 232
- Chapter 231
- Chapter 230
- Chapter 229
- Chapter 228
- Chapter 227
- Chapter 226
- Chapter 225
- Chapter 224
- Chapter 223
- Chapter 222
- Chapter 221
- Chapter 220
- Chapter 219
- Chapter 218
- Chapter 217
- Chapter 216
- Chapter 215
- Chapter 214
- Chapter 213
- Chapter 212
- Chapter 211
- Chapter 210
- Chapter 209
- Chapter 208
- Chapter 207
- Chapter 206
- Chapter 205
- Chapter 204
- Chapter 203
- Chapter 202
- Chapter 201
- Chapter 200
- Chapter 199
- Chapter 198
- Chapter 197
- Chapter 196
- Chapter 195
- Chapter 194
- Chapter 193
- Chapter 192
- Chapter 191
- Chapter 190
- Chapter 189
- Chapter 188
- Chapter 187
- Chapter 186
- Chapter 185
- Chapter 184
- Chapter 183
- Chapter 182
- Chapter 181
- Chapter 180
- Chapter 179
- Chapter 178
- Chapter 177
- Chapter 176
- Chapter 175
- Chapter 174
- Chapter 173
- Chapter 172
- Chapter 171
- Chapter 170
- Chapter 169
- Chapter 168
- Chapter 167
- Chapter 166
- Chapter 165
- Chapter 164
- Chapter 163
- Chapter 162
- Chapter 161
- Chapter 160
- Chapter 159
- Chapter 158
- Chapter 157
- Chapter 156
- Chapter 155
- Chapter 154
- Chapter 153
- Chapter 152
- Chapter 151
- Chapter 150
- Chapter 149
- Chapter 148
- Chapter 147
- Chapter 146
- Chapter 145
- Chapter 144
- Chapter 143
- Chapter 142
- Chapter 141
- Chapter 140
- Chapter 139
- Chapter 138
- Chapter 137
- Chapter 136
- Chapter 135
- Chapter 134
- Chapter 133
- Chapter 132
- Chapter 131
- Chapter 130
- Chapter 129
- Chapter 128
- Chapter 127
- Chapter 126
- Chapter 125
- Chapter 124
- Chapter 123
- Chapter 122
- Chapter 121
- Chapter 120
- Chapter 119
- Chapter 118
- Chapter 117
- Chapter 116
- Chapter 115
- Chapter 114
- Chapter 113
- Chapter 112
- Chapter 111
- Chapter 110
- Chapter 109
- Chapter 108
- Chapter 107
- Chapter 106
- Chapter 105
- Chapter 104
- Chapter 103
- Chapter 102
- Chapter 101
- Chapter 100
- Chapter 99
- Chapter 98
- Chapter 97
- Chapter 96
- Chapter 95
- Chapter 94
- Chapter 93
- Chapter 92
- Chapter 91
- Chapter 90
- Chapter 89
- Chapter 88
- Chapter 87
- Chapter 86
- Chapter 85
- Chapter 84
- Chapter 83
- Chapter 82
- Chapter 81
- Chapter 80
- Chapter 79
- Chapter 78
- Chapter 77
- Chapter 76
- Chapter 75
- Chapter 74
- Chapter 73
- Chapter 72
- Chapter 71
- Chapter 70
- Chapter 69
- Chapter 68
- Chapter 67
- Chapter 66
- Chapter 65
- Chapter 64
- Chapter 63
- Chapter 62
- Chapter 61
- Chapter 60
- Chapter 59
- Chapter 58
- Chapter 57
- Chapter 56
- Chapter 55
- Chapter 54
- Chapter 53
- Chapter 52
- Chapter 51
- Chapter 50
- Chapter 49
- Chapter 48
- Chapter 47
- Chapter 46
- Chapter 45
- Chapter 44
- Chapter 43
- Chapter 42
- Chapter 41
- Chapter 40
- Chapter 39
- Chapter 38
- Chapter 37
- Chapter 36
- Chapter 35
- Chapter 34
- Chapter 33
- Chapter 32
- Chapter 31
- Chapter 30
- Chapter 29
- Chapter 28
- Chapter 27
- Chapter 26
- Chapter 25
- Chapter 24
- Chapter 23
- Chapter 22
- Chapter 21
- Chapter 20
- Chapter 19
- Chapter 18
- Chapter 17
- Chapter 16
- Chapter 15
- Chapter 14
- Chapter 13
- Chapter 12
- Chapter 11
- Chapter 10
- Chapter 9
- Chapter 8
- Chapter 7
- Chapter 6
- Chapter 5
- Chapter 4
- Chapter 3
- Chapter 2
- Chapter 1
Comments