The Football Legends System
Chapter 85: The FA Cup Final had begun
- Chapter 152 - 2030 FIFA World Cup Final: [ULTIMATE CHALLENGE COMPLETE! You have achieved the rank of UNDISPUTED GOAT!]
- Chapter 151: Villa Park’s Fury and the Unwavering Verdict
- Chapter 150: Unreachable benchmark for midfielders
- Chapter 149: The Foxes’ Fury and the Unseen Web
- Chapter 148: The Toon Army’s Fury and the Unstoppable Engine
- Chapter 147: The Unyielding Iron Will
- Chapter 146: The Clarets’ Test and the Ultimate Adaptability
- Chapter 145: The Dazzling Destroyer
- Chapter 144: The Hammer’s Wall and the Unseen Thread
- Chapter 143: The fastest player in Manchester United history
- Chapter 142: Making the difficult look simple, consistently
- Chapter 141: Scored or assisted in every Champions League group stage match
- Chapter 140: The Midfield Cannon
- Chapter 139: The Lion’s Roar and the Maestro’s Mark
- Chapter 138: The Amex Revenge and the Spirit of the Game
- Chapter 137: The Bees’ Den and the Unwavering Force
- Chapter 136: The Dragon’s Roar and the Zenith of Control
- Chapter 135: True Face of the Premier League
- Chapter 134: The Perpetual Zenith of Messi
- Chapter 133: The Dragons’ Lair and the Ultimate Masterpiece
- Chapter 132: The Seagulls’ Lair and the Game’s New Blueprint
- Chapter 131: The Blades’ Defense and the Unrivaled Zenith
- Chapter 130: Relentless Wave of Cruyff’s Barcelona
- Chapter 129: The Toffees’ Rematch and a Thread of Genius
- Chapter 128: Tottenham’s Fire and the Unending Pursuit
- Chapter 127: The Galatasaray Storm and the Unyielding Aura
- Chapter 126: The Impossible Turn of Bergkamp
- Chapter 125: Goodison’s Gauntlet and the Legend’s Touch
- Chapter 124: The Bees’ Sting and a Glimpse of Omniscience
- Chapter 123: San Siro Symphony and the Tempo Maestro
- Chapter 122: The Tempo Dictators and Game Managers
- Chapter 121: Parisian Starlight and the Strategic Catalyst
- Chapter 120: Villa’s Fury and the Sculptor’s Touch
- Chapter 119: Anfield’s Roar and the Cruyff Conductor
- Chapter 118: The Seagulls’ Dance and a Puppeteer’s Masterclass
- Chapter 117: The Toffees’ Test and a Woven Masterpiece
- Chapter 116: St. James’ Inferno and the Steel in the Spine
- Chapter 115: FA Cup Magic and a Phantom Dance
- Chapter 114: The Crowned Kings and a Deeper Game
- Chapter 113: The Bavarian Giant and the Iron Will
- Chapter 112: The Blue Inferno and a Tireless Engine
- Chapter 111: Derby Days and a Brazilian Blaze
- Chapter 110: Madrid Miracle and the Golden Touch
- Chapter 109: The Royal Test and a Visionary Pass
- Chapter 108: Red Devils, Red Haze
- Chapter 107: The Final Showdown: England vs Germany
- Chapter 106: The Samba Kings and a Shot at Glory
- Chapter 105: The Speed Demon and the Shadow
- Chapter 104: Iron Walls and a Drogba Dream
- Chapter 103: Mastering the Glide and the Stars and Stripes
- Chapter 102: A New Spark
- Chapter 101: Your current Overall Rating
- Chapter 100: Tears And Truth
- Chapter 99: ENGLAND vs ARGENTINA
- Chapter 98: [World Cup System Activated]
- Chapter 97: World Cup Opener
- Chapter 96: Arrival In New York
- Chapter 95: World Cup Training Camp
- Chapter 94: A New Horizon
- Chapter 93: The Champions League Spot
- Chapter 92: No Time to Breathe
- Chapter 91: United vs Liverpool
- Chapter 90: A Rocket and a Promise
- Chapter 89: SS-Rank Potential
- Chapter 88: [Ability & Potential]
- Chapter 87: FA Cup Champions
- Chapter 86: Breaking the Balance
- Chapter 85: The FA Cup Final had begun
- Chapter 84: [New Feature Unlocked – System Store!]
- Chapter 83: They Think We’re Finished
- Chapter 82: Chelsea Night
- Chapter 81: Cameras and Angry Eyes
- Chapter 80: A Magical Team Attack
- Chapter 79: End of a Crazy Half
- Chapter 78: Rest and Preparation
- Chapter 77: From the Heart
- Chapter 76: The Silent End
- Chapter 75: Attempt to Respond
- Chapter 74: Halftime at the Bernabéu
- Chapter 73: The Bernabéu Burns Bright
- Chapter 72: On The Way To Madrid
- Chapter 71: Back to Battle
- Chapter 70: City of Champions
- Chapter 69: Everyone On The Brink
- Chapter 68: No, It’s Not Over Yet
- Chapter 67: Spirit of a Legend
- Chapter 66: Nathan Passes But No One Receives
- Chapter 65: Let’s see what this skill can do
- Chapter 64: The Edge of Collapse
- Chapter 63: Tired of being the golden boy
- Chapter 62: A Night That Wouldn’t Let Go
- Chapter 61: UEFA’s Champions League
- Chapter 60: From Boy To Star
- Chapter 59: Manchester United vs Arsenal
- Chapter 58: No Mercy at Elland Road
- Chapter 57: Man United Match
- Chapter 56: The Transfer Market Report
- Chapter 55: The New Star
- Chapter 54: A Wild Extra Time
- Chapter 53: Time for Speed and Composure
- Chapter 52: A Moment Without Noise
- Chapter 51: A Name in the Firelight
- Chapter 50: Champions League Night
- Chapter 49: The Greatest Derby of the Decade
- Chapter 48: Manchester United vs Manchester City
- Chapter 47: Matchday – Group Stage, Match 2
- Chapter 46: A New Test for the Wonderkid
- Chapter 45: Between Heart and Field
- Chapter 44: AC MILAN VS MAN UNITED
- Chapter 43: The Champions League Begins
- Chapter 42: MAN UNITED VS CHELSEA
- Chapter 41: Still Standing
- Chapter 40: Premier League Lights
- Chapter 39: News That Flooded the Headlines
- Chapter 38: Battle of Thoughts
- Chapter 37: An Unforgettable Ending
- Chapter 36: Fighting to the Final Breath
- Chapter 35: The Fearsome Skill
- Chapter 34: A Dream Boy
- Chapter 33: The Final Climb
- Chapter 32: A Real Wonderkid
- Chapter 31: The Legendary Spirit
- Chapter 30: [Legendary Spirit Unlocked]
- Chapter 29: Inches and Fire
- Chapter 28: A World-Class Goal
- Chapter 27: A 30-yard free kick
- Chapter 26: Let’s Go Make History
- Chapter 25: The Match Day
- Chapter 24: FA Cup Fourth Round
- Chapter 23: What the Bar Took
- Chapter 22: I was supposed to show them
- Chapter 21: Just Inches
- Chapter 20: LEEDS VS NORWICH
- Chapter 19: Tomorrow... I’ll show them
- Chapter 18: A New Hero at Elland Road?
- Chapter 17: Heartbeats at the Edge
- Chapter 16: The Miracle at 118 Minutes
- Chapter 15: COME ON, LEEDS! BELIEVE!
- Chapter 14: LEEDS VS IPSWICH TOWN (2)
- Chapter 13: LEEDS VS IPSWICH TOWN (1)
- Chapter 12: Defensive Aura
- Chapter 11: I want to be the best
- Chapter 10: LEEDS VS BURNLEY (3)
- Chapter 9: LEEDS VS BURNLEY (2)
- Chapter 8: LEEDS VS BURNLEY (1)
- Chapter 7: Baptism by Burnley
- Chapter 6: You’ve got potential, kid
- Chapter 5: The first team
- Chapter 4 - 5v5 Game
- Chapter 3: Unlock a Random Skill
- Chapter 2: Daddy’s Boy?. Fine
- Chapter 1: Daddy’s Boy!
Chapter 85 - The FA Cup Final had begun
10th Minute — Left Wing, Wembley
Valverde barely looked before threading the line-breaking pass——a low bullet down the left channel.
Nathan was already on the move. Touch tight. Pace perfect.
Thud!
He killed the ball with the outside of his boot and lifted his head.Grealish in front of him. Bernardo Silva sliding in to help. Walker closing the angle.
Three men.
Nathan’s pulse quickened—but not from fear.
From instinct.
Tap. Tap-tap.A feint left. He burst right.
"HAAH!"
Grealish was gone.
Bernardo lunged—swipe!—but Nathan danced over his foot, clipped the ball behind him, then spun into a roulette that cracked through both remaining gaps—
Whirr—ZIP!
Walker reached for him—but only caught air.
Nathan broke through, the ball glued to his foot like magic, and swung a cross with his weaker foot—
"Zirkzee!"
The striker leapt, twisted—
BOOM!
Header!
It flashed just wide of the post.
"OHHHHHHH!!!"
The crowd gasped as one.
Even Guardiola bit his lip. Amorim clapped furiously on the sideline.
Nathan exhaled, jogging back.
His heart thudded in rhythm with the drums of Wembley.He was alive in a different way now.
The Spirit of Neymar wasn’t just in his feet—it was in his breath.
In his blood.
15th Minute
City responded like champions.
Rodri fed De Bruyne in the half-space. The Belgian flicked it on with the outside of his boot.
Slide—BOOM!
Haaland exploded into space, brushed off Varane like he wasn’t there.
Onana was ready.
THUD!
He dove low, one hand stretched.
Saved.
The keeper popped back up like a coil and roared at his defense.
"WAKE UP!"
Even at full stretch, he looked furious.
—
20th Minute
Casemiro picked off a lazy Foden pass and immediately spotted the opening.
He slipped it left to Valverde, who took one touch—
Then fired from 30 meters out!
BOOM!!
Ederson’s fingertips barely grazed it—
CLANG!
Tipped just over the bar!
Corner.
The United bench surged to its feet. Valverde pumped a fist.
Amorim barked from the sideline:
"KEEP THE PRESSURE!"
—
24th Minute
Foden took revenge.
He danced past Dalot, who stumbled. Whipped in a laser cross—
Haaland again!
CRACK!
Header! Just inches wide of the post.
The City end groaned. Haaland pounded the ground in frustration.
The tempo was blistering.
Finals weren’t usually this open—but this was more than a final.
—
29th Minute
Xavi Simons, slick with sweat, turned sharply and pinged the ball wide to Nathan again.
Walker stepped up.
But Nathan had already baited him.
He dropped his shoulder left—
Tap!
Walker bit.
Nathan flicked the ball behind with a reverse drag, spun inside, then slipped a cheeky backheel to Zirkzee who’d peeled off into space!
THWACK!
Zirkzee hit it first-time!
But Ederson was sharp—caught it clean.
"Tch..."
Nathan clenched his fists.
They were getting closer.
He could feel it.
—
30th Minute — 0-0
The air was electric. Like the stormclouds of footballing gods were about to collide.
No goals.
But no breath wasted either.
Every run. Every pass. Every shot—charged with desperation.
And then—the break.
—
33rd Minute
Valverde and Bruno linked like they were tied by thread.
One-two. Three-four.
The rhythm of elite midfielders.
City’s press was disjointed.
Nathan floated wide again, hugging the sideline. 𝗳𝗿𝐞𝕖𝘄𝗲𝕓𝗻𝚘𝚟𝕖𝐥.𝚌𝕠𝕞
Valverde looked once—sent it.
Thup!
Nathan received calmly.Bernardo Silva approached, teeth gritted.
Nathan didn’t rush.
A beat.A glance.Then—roulette.
Whrrr... CLICK!
Past him.
Rodri stepped up. Bigger. Stronger.
Nathan chopped left, then doubled a stepover, then dragged the ball diagonally across his body.
Rodri reached out—
Gone.
Aké was the final man.
Nathan barely touched the ball—just pushed it forward with a feathered toe tap.
Into the box.
The roar of the crowd started to rise.
"Go on...!"
Nathan inhaled—
Then unleashed it.
CRACK!!
A curling rocket from the tightest angle, kissed with venom and madness.
CLANG!
OFF THE CROSSBAR—AND IN.
Wembley exploded.
"AAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!"
Commentator:
"A goal from another planet! Neymar’s flair... Van Persie’s strike... Nathan’s spirit!"
Nathan sprinted to the corner flag, slid on his knees, hands raised to the sky.
Zirkzee tackled him. Bruno wrapped his arms around both. The bench poured out like a red wave.
The scoreboard burned bright:
Manchester United 1 – 0 Manchester City
—
"That’s one. We’re not done."
—
42nd Minute
City weren’t going to lie down.
Foden shifted gears again, combining with De Bruyne on the edge of the box.
De Bruyne turned—
Boom!
Low shot.
Onana blocked it with a diving palm—But it spun out for a corner.
Nathan trotted back, locking eyes with Foden briefly.
No fear. No grin.
The corner came in—high, fast.
Cleared.
But it bounced awkwardly... right to Haaland.
BOOM!!
A low rocket!
Onana dived again!
Thud!
Another save!
But this time—
Tch—no one cleared it fast enough!
Varane stumbled trying to hook it away.
Savinho, fresh off the bench, pounced.
He ghosted past Casemiro. Then skipped past Lisandro.
Left foot. Bottom corner.
Tap—THUNK!
Goal.
The City end erupted.
United players froze.
Varane dropped to a crouch, clutching his head.
Amorim screamed in frustration, slamming his fist into the dugout wall.
—
44th Minute
Nathan stood near the halfway line.
Breathing. Processing.
The high of the goal still echoed in his limbs—but the equalizer had carved right through the euphoria.
Bruno jogged past and clapped his shoulder.
"This ain’t over. You know it."
Nathan nodded.
—
45+1 Minute — Wembley Tunnel
The whistle echoed.
The first half was over.
Players trudged off the pitch, sweat glistening, expressions locked somewhere between anger and disbelief.
Nathan didn’t say a word.
Valverde stormed past, muttering curses under his breath in Spanish. His eyes blazed with fury as he barked at Lisandro and Dalot, "How do we let one chance ruin forty-five minutes of dominance?!"
Behind them, Onana’s voice cut through the corridor.
"Why did you play it like that?!""VARANE—WHY?!"
Varane didn’t respond. He stared at the ground, his jaw clenched.
The tension was suffocating. Nathan could feel it gripping the walls, curling around the boots of every player.
But he kept walking. Step by step.His mind? Already in the second half.
There’s still time.This is just the beginning.
—
Locker Room — Manchester United
The room was quiet. Too quiet.
The sound of cleats scuffing the floor. Water bottles twisting open. Breathing. Nothing else.
Then Amorim stood.
"Focus."
He scanned the players, locking eyes with each of them.
"City aren’t unbeatable. You’re making them look it."
He turned sharply to Varane.
"You handed them that goal. I don’t care if you’ve won the World Cup. Focus. Or I’ll sub you."
Varane didn’t flinch—but his throat bobbed.
Amorim turned to Nathan.
"Keep going. Don’t stop. Take risks. You’re opening them up."
Nathan nodded once, silently.
"Valverde," the coach continued, "don’t let up. Stay aggressive. Stay you."
Valverde grunted. Still steaming.
"Everyone else—raise your level."
Then, he paused... and finished softly.
"You don’t get second chances in finals."
Nathan leaned forward, elbows on his knees, staring down at his boots.
Let’s end this story our way.
—
46th Minute — Second Half Kickoff
Fweeeeeet!!
The whistle blew.
United flew forward.
The game wasn’t waiting, and neither were they.
—
47th Minute
Xavi Simons skipped through midfield like a dancer, slipping between Rodri and Gvardiol, then fed it left.
Nathan collected with a smooth touch, dragged the ball inside, then—
Whip!A dangerous cross!
But Aké rose highest. Cleared it just in time.
Still, the pressure was back on.
—
48th Minute
Bruno.
He picked the ball up 25 yards out. Took one glance.
Then struck.
BOOM!
The ball screamed toward the top corner.
"OHHHH!!"
Just inches over.
Bruno let out a frustrated grunt and jogged back, brushing the sweat from his brow.
"Damn it... it’s coming. It’s coming..."
Nathan looked at him and nodded.
He believed it too.
—
49th Minute
Valverde stole the ball at the halfway line—then launched it forward with a cutting pass.
Zirkzee ran onto it clean.
One-on-one.
THUMP!
He shot low and hard!
Ederson exploded forward—
THUD!
A world-class save! Legs wide. Timing perfect.
The City fans roared.The United fans groaned.
Nathan closed his eyes, then stomped the turf in frustration.
Tch... another chance wasted.
Bruno held his head.Valverde slapped the ground.
But something stirred in the crowd.
"UNITED! UNITED! UNITED!"
The chant wasn’t just support—it was fire.
The feeling shifted.
From disappointment... to belief.
- Chapter 152 - 2030 FIFA World Cup Final: [ULTIMATE CHALLENGE COMPLETE! You have achieved the rank of UNDISPUTED GOAT!]
- Chapter 151: Villa Park’s Fury and the Unwavering Verdict
- Chapter 150: Unreachable benchmark for midfielders
- Chapter 149: The Foxes’ Fury and the Unseen Web
- Chapter 148: The Toon Army’s Fury and the Unstoppable Engine
- Chapter 147: The Unyielding Iron Will
- Chapter 146: The Clarets’ Test and the Ultimate Adaptability
- Chapter 145: The Dazzling Destroyer
- Chapter 144: The Hammer’s Wall and the Unseen Thread
- Chapter 143: The fastest player in Manchester United history
- Chapter 142: Making the difficult look simple, consistently
- Chapter 141: Scored or assisted in every Champions League group stage match
- Chapter 140: The Midfield Cannon
- Chapter 139: The Lion’s Roar and the Maestro’s Mark
- Chapter 138: The Amex Revenge and the Spirit of the Game
- Chapter 137: The Bees’ Den and the Unwavering Force
- Chapter 136: The Dragon’s Roar and the Zenith of Control
- Chapter 135: True Face of the Premier League
- Chapter 134: The Perpetual Zenith of Messi
- Chapter 133: The Dragons’ Lair and the Ultimate Masterpiece
- Chapter 132: The Seagulls’ Lair and the Game’s New Blueprint
- Chapter 131: The Blades’ Defense and the Unrivaled Zenith
- Chapter 130: Relentless Wave of Cruyff’s Barcelona
- Chapter 129: The Toffees’ Rematch and a Thread of Genius
- Chapter 128: Tottenham’s Fire and the Unending Pursuit
- Chapter 127: The Galatasaray Storm and the Unyielding Aura
- Chapter 126: The Impossible Turn of Bergkamp
- Chapter 125: Goodison’s Gauntlet and the Legend’s Touch
- Chapter 124: The Bees’ Sting and a Glimpse of Omniscience
- Chapter 123: San Siro Symphony and the Tempo Maestro
- Chapter 122: The Tempo Dictators and Game Managers
- Chapter 121: Parisian Starlight and the Strategic Catalyst
- Chapter 120: Villa’s Fury and the Sculptor’s Touch
- Chapter 119: Anfield’s Roar and the Cruyff Conductor
- Chapter 118: The Seagulls’ Dance and a Puppeteer’s Masterclass
- Chapter 117: The Toffees’ Test and a Woven Masterpiece
- Chapter 116: St. James’ Inferno and the Steel in the Spine
- Chapter 115: FA Cup Magic and a Phantom Dance
- Chapter 114: The Crowned Kings and a Deeper Game
- Chapter 113: The Bavarian Giant and the Iron Will
- Chapter 112: The Blue Inferno and a Tireless Engine
- Chapter 111: Derby Days and a Brazilian Blaze
- Chapter 110: Madrid Miracle and the Golden Touch
- Chapter 109: The Royal Test and a Visionary Pass
- Chapter 108: Red Devils, Red Haze
- Chapter 107: The Final Showdown: England vs Germany
- Chapter 106: The Samba Kings and a Shot at Glory
- Chapter 105: The Speed Demon and the Shadow
- Chapter 104: Iron Walls and a Drogba Dream
- Chapter 103: Mastering the Glide and the Stars and Stripes
- Chapter 102: A New Spark
- Chapter 101: Your current Overall Rating
- Chapter 100: Tears And Truth
- Chapter 99: ENGLAND vs ARGENTINA
- Chapter 98: [World Cup System Activated]
- Chapter 97: World Cup Opener
- Chapter 96: Arrival In New York
- Chapter 95: World Cup Training Camp
- Chapter 94: A New Horizon
- Chapter 93: The Champions League Spot
- Chapter 92: No Time to Breathe
- Chapter 91: United vs Liverpool
- Chapter 90: A Rocket and a Promise
- Chapter 89: SS-Rank Potential
- Chapter 88: [Ability & Potential]
- Chapter 87: FA Cup Champions
- Chapter 86: Breaking the Balance
- Chapter 85: The FA Cup Final had begun
- Chapter 84: [New Feature Unlocked – System Store!]
- Chapter 83: They Think We’re Finished
- Chapter 82: Chelsea Night
- Chapter 81: Cameras and Angry Eyes
- Chapter 80: A Magical Team Attack
- Chapter 79: End of a Crazy Half
- Chapter 78: Rest and Preparation
- Chapter 77: From the Heart
- Chapter 76: The Silent End
- Chapter 75: Attempt to Respond
- Chapter 74: Halftime at the Bernabéu
- Chapter 73: The Bernabéu Burns Bright
- Chapter 72: On The Way To Madrid
- Chapter 71: Back to Battle
- Chapter 70: City of Champions
- Chapter 69: Everyone On The Brink
- Chapter 68: No, It’s Not Over Yet
- Chapter 67: Spirit of a Legend
- Chapter 66: Nathan Passes But No One Receives
- Chapter 65: Let’s see what this skill can do
- Chapter 64: The Edge of Collapse
- Chapter 63: Tired of being the golden boy
- Chapter 62: A Night That Wouldn’t Let Go
- Chapter 61: UEFA’s Champions League
- Chapter 60: From Boy To Star
- Chapter 59: Manchester United vs Arsenal
- Chapter 58: No Mercy at Elland Road
- Chapter 57: Man United Match
- Chapter 56: The Transfer Market Report
- Chapter 55: The New Star
- Chapter 54: A Wild Extra Time
- Chapter 53: Time for Speed and Composure
- Chapter 52: A Moment Without Noise
- Chapter 51: A Name in the Firelight
- Chapter 50: Champions League Night
- Chapter 49: The Greatest Derby of the Decade
- Chapter 48: Manchester United vs Manchester City
- Chapter 47: Matchday – Group Stage, Match 2
- Chapter 46: A New Test for the Wonderkid
- Chapter 45: Between Heart and Field
- Chapter 44: AC MILAN VS MAN UNITED
- Chapter 43: The Champions League Begins
- Chapter 42: MAN UNITED VS CHELSEA
- Chapter 41: Still Standing
- Chapter 40: Premier League Lights
- Chapter 39: News That Flooded the Headlines
- Chapter 38: Battle of Thoughts
- Chapter 37: An Unforgettable Ending
- Chapter 36: Fighting to the Final Breath
- Chapter 35: The Fearsome Skill
- Chapter 34: A Dream Boy
- Chapter 33: The Final Climb
- Chapter 32: A Real Wonderkid
- Chapter 31: The Legendary Spirit
- Chapter 30: [Legendary Spirit Unlocked]
- Chapter 29: Inches and Fire
- Chapter 28: A World-Class Goal
- Chapter 27: A 30-yard free kick
- Chapter 26: Let’s Go Make History
- Chapter 25: The Match Day
- Chapter 24: FA Cup Fourth Round
- Chapter 23: What the Bar Took
- Chapter 22: I was supposed to show them
- Chapter 21: Just Inches
- Chapter 20: LEEDS VS NORWICH
- Chapter 19: Tomorrow... I’ll show them
- Chapter 18: A New Hero at Elland Road?
- Chapter 17: Heartbeats at the Edge
- Chapter 16: The Miracle at 118 Minutes
- Chapter 15: COME ON, LEEDS! BELIEVE!
- Chapter 14: LEEDS VS IPSWICH TOWN (2)
- Chapter 13: LEEDS VS IPSWICH TOWN (1)
- Chapter 12: Defensive Aura
- Chapter 11: I want to be the best
- Chapter 10: LEEDS VS BURNLEY (3)
- Chapter 9: LEEDS VS BURNLEY (2)
- Chapter 8: LEEDS VS BURNLEY (1)
- Chapter 7: Baptism by Burnley
- Chapter 6: You’ve got potential, kid
- Chapter 5: The first team
- Chapter 4 - 5v5 Game
- Chapter 3: Unlock a Random Skill
- Chapter 2: Daddy’s Boy?. Fine
- Chapter 1: Daddy’s Boy!
Comments